Showing posts with label Israel-Palestine. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Israel-Palestine. Show all posts

Monday, 18 November 2013

Women-only cafes offer new versions of Palestinian public Space

Original source:http://www.maannews.net/eng/ViewDetails.aspx?ID=643647


Discreetly located at the foot of a staircase, the cafe offers a familiar scene: shisha pipes are stacked neatly on the counter, ashtrays dot each table, Lebanese satellite television plays in the background and steaming Turkish coffee is served to a table of regulars. 

Like many other cafes lining the busy avenues branching off of Ramallah’s bustling Manara Square, this is a gendered space. Male employees stand guard outside, surveying the entrance of the cafe with stern eyes.

Unlike most public establishments in Ramallah, Ladies is a cafe for women only.

When the cafe opened in early 2012, it was the first women-only cafe in Ramallah. As in most cities in Palestine, cafes in Ramallah are primarily a men-only affair. Many cafes and restaurants have mixed clientele and some even have delineated "family" sections, but for the most part women rarely frequent cafes on their own.

Ladies promised to provide a different experience, one that barred male clientele and instead offered a public space intended exclusively for women. The hope was that in a society where cafes are traditionally geared towards men, the creation of a women-only cafe would offer women equal access to the public sphere, but on their own terms.

Cafe owner Jamil Ali explains that in a woman-only space, women can feel comfortable and take off their scarves, smoke cigarettes and sit with their legs crossed, unlike in male-dominated cafes where these behaviors might draw attention. 

"She doesn’t want anybody to look at her," he says. "A thousand eyes will go to her, a thousand eyes." But in a public space frequented exclusively by women, she is free to unwind in a comfortable setting. 

In addition to creating a space accessible to women, Ali also sought to ensure that the cafe be economically accessible to a female-only clientele. As he explained, many mixed cafes charge prices out of reach for most Palestinian women. Although the entire menu was originally priced at 10 shekels ($3), after realizing that the prices were still too high for some patrons, the price of drinks were lowered to seven shekels ($2).

"Women don’t have to be on their guard." 

Unlike Jamil Ali, Susie Atilla didn’t set out to create a women-only space three years ago when she co-founded Diva, a cafe patronized predominantly by women inconspicuously located off of a main street in Bethlehem.

Atilla was originally encouraged by the male owner of the commercial center where Diva is located to open the cafe there because a number of other female-oriented businesses had locations nearby. Among Diva’s neighbors are a gym, hairdresser and a Turkish bath.

She explains that even though the cafe was open to a mixed clientele, "the reputation spread that it’s only for women."

"Some men get really embarrassed to come with their wives but we always tell them men and families are welcome!" she adds with a chuckle.

Susie and her sister, Nancy, started Diva as a project meant to provide them with an income for after their retirement from their day jobs. They hoped in the process to create a place where they and their friends could come and socialize. 

When asked about Ladies cafe in Ramallah, Atilla smiles. 

"It’s great for girls to be able to feel comfortable," in a cafe like Ladies. "Women don’t have to be on their guard."

She emphasizes that even though its location is somewhat isolated, Diva offers "privacy," and a place where women feel comfortable. 

The sentiment was shared by many patrons at Ladies interviewed by Ma’an.

A patron from the US uses the cafe as a space for lessons with teenage Palestinian girls she tutors. The parents of the girls, she says, feel comfortable knowing that the cafe only serves women and thus offers a secure public meeting spot for young girls. 

Many of the students’ parents usually only allow their daughters to go to school and come home, the tutor says, but when they heard about the cafe they welcomed the idea.

She concedes, however, that gender-segregated cafes "enforce the idea that girls have to do things in secret."

A Palestinian woman at the cafe adds, "It’s sick, the separation thing. Ramallah is better (than other cities in Palestine, but) you still find people who won’t let their daughters or wives go places."

This customer tells Ma'an that she sees a women-only cafe as another example of the kinds of separation between genders that persists in Palestinian public space. 

She adds that the cafe’s decision to serve an exclusively female clientele furthers the gender divide between men and women in public spaces. 

"The society and the mentality of the people is not going to change soon," she says with a shake of her head.

Creating public spaces for women 

Both cafes, though quite different in mission, have become spaces for women located in a larger urban context that offer comfort and privacy for their patrons. Neither cafe set out to change the fabric of Palestinian society, or the fact that most public establishments primarily cater exclusively to men. 

Rather, each cafe acknowledges the realities of a male-dominated public sphere by offering a place where women can feel comfortable.

Even though all-women cafes like Ladies "(enforce) the separation," a Palestinian patron says, they can also be seen as "a solution that make things easier for some part of society."

And for the many women who frequent Ladies and Diva, but feel uncomfortable or unable to patronize male-dominated establishments, these cafes offer a unique and inviting alternative that offers comfort, privacy, and access.

Atilla, the owner of Diva suggests that "some women in society feel like they need to have a place that is private and that’s where they feel comfortable."

Tuesday, 23 July 2013

Jewish Women battle discrimination in Israel

Original Source-http://www.thestar.com/opinion/commentary/2013/06/23/jewish_women_battle_discrimination_in_israel_siddiqui.html

Researcher- Avantika Lal

Shira Ben-Sasson Furstenberg is an Israeli women’s rights activist. She organizes “freedom rides” to help end gender segregation on public transit buses travelling through ultra-Orthodox neighbourhoods.
Israeli courts have held that women may voluntarily sit at the back of the bus and enter and exit through a back door, but they don’t have to. However, few women have moved up front, and some of them have been harassed by men.
“I am Orthodox and observant but I don’t want to sit separately in a bus,” says Furstenberg, a former officer of the Israeli Defense Forces.
“So, some of us have been conducting freedom rides — inviting tourists and others to sit in the men’s section. I went and sat in the second row. As the men came, they wouldn’t sit next to me or in the seats around me. I was not spoken to by the men. Nobody touched me or hurt me but it was not fun.”
Jewish zealots have cursed and spat at school girls deemed immodestly dressed. Vandals have blacked out faces of women from ads on buses and billboards.
Under pressure to do something, the Benjamin Netanyahu government plans to outlaw gender discrimination on buses, health clinics, cemeteries and radio waves, and make humiliation of women in public spaces a criminal offence.

Furstenberg is involved in another “war zone” — to end gender bias at the Western Wall in Jerusalem.
Since 1988, activists of the Women of the Wall have been turning up on Rosh Hodesh, the first day of the Hebrew month, to worship. Instead of praying quietly in a separate section, they do what only men have done by tradition — chant verses from the Torah and wear the talit, fringed prayer shawl.
Some were arrested for disturbing public order. Last month, thousands of Orthodox women turned up early in the morning to block the Women of the Wall, who were taunted and abused by men in black hats throwing water and plastic chairs.
Furstenberg joined the activists on two occasions. “I got yelled at. I got called names. I was filmed. It’s a real war zone.”
Under a recent court ruling, the arrests have stopped. And the government has promised to allow different ways of praying at the holy site. It has also pledged full participation of women in state ceremonies.
Progress is becoming possible because the ultra-Orthodox, a minority that for years exercised disproportionate power in coalition governments, are no longer part of Netanyahu’s current coalition.
He is under pressure also to reduce military service exemptions and welfare subsidies to the ultra-Orthodox, and ease their control of religious institutions and practices, including marriage, divorce, conversions and burials.
“The majority of Israelis have to bow down to the Orthodox monopoly, even though there’s more than one way of being Jewish,” says Furstenberg. For example, “there’s only one female rabbi on state payroll. There’s only one way to divorce. Under get laws, only the husband can give divorce. And the rabbinical courts go along with the husbands’ demands — he would not pay support or he would dictate on how the kids are to be educated. There’s a lot of blackmail.”
Furstenberg was invited to Canada by the New Israel Fund , and spoke at the Beth Tzedec Congregation Monday and at a Jewish centre in Vancouver later in the week. With her was Yossi Beilin, a former Labor minister, former member of the Israeli Knesset and a long-time advocate of peace with Palestinians. He spoke in Toronto and Montreal.
I interviewed both together.
He said social divisions in Israel — especially over the secular-religious fault line — usually come to the fore when the security issue is less paramount.
To him, the issue of gender equity at the Wall “is not the most important. The need for the separation of church and state is the main issue.”
“The matrimonial law is especially unacceptable. Many Israelis bypass it by opting for civil marriage.
“On the bus issue, the ultra-Orthodox argue that women are sitting separately voluntarily. But not all are doing it voluntarily. They are doing it because they are afraid of family and neighbours. They are frightened of their rabbis.”
But he’s happy that discrimination is being challenged and that change is coming, albeit slowly.

Sunday, 21 July 2013

Women's Empowerment and Peace building under occupation

Original Source:http://www.pij.org/details.php?id=1373

As a contribution to the discussion on women’s empowerment in the Palestine-Israel Journal, this article reflects on the possibilities for women’s empowerment and peace-building under a condition of prolonged occupation. Specifically, it focuses on the near-impossibility of the manifestation of empowerment and peace for those who have been disenfranchised under a paradigm of extreme oppression in the context of Occupied Palestine. If one uses Eileen Kuttab’s contextualization of Palestinian empowerment as historically being embodied in practices of mobilization and resistance, then being allowed neither mobility nor the right to organize resistance to Israeli military violence makes it clear that the prospects for successful peace-building and the realization of Palestinian women’s empowerment face significant obstacles.1 This is a result of the autocratic imbalance of power that has seeped from external into internal dynamics. The external factors are the architects and participants of the occupation comprised of an illegal Israeli military occupation force of women and men, abetted by an international community that does not adhere to its mandates to the fullest extent and follows an aid praxis that further serves to annihilate mobilization and resistance. The internal obstacles to women’s empowerment are an extension of the external, that is, elements of the Palestinian local governing structure that was meant to be temporary in nature.
Different Manifestations of the Basis of Supremacy
To understand this analysis, it is imperative to pay attention to the overall environment and the multiplicity of factors within it. The existence of an Occupied Palestine is made possible through applying the concept of the “other,” which Edward Said eloquently elaborates in his book Orientalism. Said’s work on Orientalism is related to the notion of the subaltern as he explains the way in which Orientalism produced the silence of the Orientals. The term “subaltern” generally refers to marginalized groups rendered without agency.2 Thus, European colonialists defined themselves by defining and presenting the differences of the “other”3 as a guise for colonial exploitation. The shift from standard European colonialism toward a policy-oriented neo-colonialism under various U.S. administrations driven by the military industrial complex has led to different manifestations of this basis of supremacy, which in recent times has been accompanied by the rhetoric of the right to development under occupation.4
Annihilation of the “Other’s” Identity and Aspirations
Through the State of Israel, a regime of militarized, patriarchal colonialism has been executed by implementing extreme measures in order to alter, if not eradicate, the sociality of the “other” or the Palestinian.5 Colonialism in Occupied Palestine lies in the practice of habituating the population to defeat and constructing normalcy out of that very subjugation. Continuous movement and encroachment on space accompanies this stillness of subjugation, which is necessary to achieve the annihilation of the other’s identity and aspirations. The self of the Palestinian is replaced through the establishment of an ethnocentric state and the deconstruction and construction that the project necessarily entails. This includes building colonial infrastructure such as settlements and settler (Jewish-only) roads and severely restricting mobility and accessibility through checkpoints, soldiers, machine guns and an impenetrable bureaucracy of control that administers every aspect of Palestinians’ lives.6 The most visible structure to date has been the Separation Wall, which may be perceived as the attempt to slice the Palestinians’ location and memory from their homeland. Correspondingly, destroying homes and creating a complex network of checkpoint passages which dictate where Palestinians can go, when and for how long, and ensuing expulsion engenders perpetual states of dislocation, insecurity and domination.7
Some activists have suggested that a solution for empowerment and peace amidst the mentioned context should emanate from collective initiatives by Israeli and Palestinian women. However, it should be considered that the occupation — its imposition of immobility and the breakdown of Palestinian society that this produces — is sustained by an occupation army formed by forced conscription that also includes Israeli women.8 Israeli women may be exempt from serving in the army due to religious, marital or other factors; however, as Rela Mazali has noted, their socialization within a culture of war renders it difficult to break out of a militarized construct.9 Militarization has been described by Cynthia Enloe as “the step-by-step process by which something becomes controlled by, dependent on, or derives its value from the military as an institution or militaristic criteria.”10 This transpires through a subtle process, which includes maneuvering women of diverse groups against one another.11 Being conditioned within a militarized framework affects and incarcerates perceptions, thoughts and behavior within militarized societies. Israeli women’s role in an illegal military apparatus may skew their comprehension of peace-building and empowerment as it relates to the cases of Palestinian women. A high probability exists that they will not have Palestinian national resistance or aspirations of self-determination as primary objectives on their agendas. Moreover, Palestinian women under occupation and the ensuing annexation of East Jerusalem have been excluded from the democratic privileges that Israeli women have enjoyed, further separating these communities.12 Despite years of the international community’s support for Palestinian/Israeli women’s dialogues for peace, these conditions should be seen to render any such conversations difficult.
Israeli Women Have More Access to Institutions That Can Implement Change
Moreover, it seems delusional to presume that simply being women, due to physiological commonalities, is sufficient to erase differences such as socioeconomic status, freedom and the carte blanche afforded to participants in an illegal occupation to negate and relinquish others’ rights. Simply being a woman does not inherently engender compassion or enable true entry into a struggle for emancipation by a female in her position of a colonizer with regard to her subjects. Nonetheless, forms of peace-building and empowerment have generally taken guidance from those that have the resources to be in a position of greater might. In the context of Israeli and Palestinian women, these have predominantly been the Israeli women. While they are also constrained by a male-dominated environment, Israeli women have more access to institutions that can implement change than Palestinian women and therefore have the ability to wield stronger impacts. It is dubious that genuine empowerment and peace-building between women can transpire amidst such asymmetrical power relations. This is not to deny that empathy and benevolent intentions exist within attempts to reach peace. Rather, the location of Israeli women outside an imposed occupation and the mundane realities that accompany that level of existence removes them from that plight. Thus, we need to understand to what extent peace-building between women can be possible when one party comprises soldiers in an illegal occupation army, actors in the quelling of a civilian population, and the other forms part of a population under occupation.13
Nevertheless, initiatives between women seem to proceed regardless of Israel’s on-going violations of international law and have proven insufficient in changing patterns of behavior. Israel continues to consistently violate the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, UN Security Council and General Assembly resolutions, customary international law as reflected in the UN Charter, the Hague Convention, the International Covenant on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights, the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights; the Convention for the Elimination of all forms of Racial Discrimination, the Convention for the Elimination of all forms of Discrimination Against Women, the Convention on the Rights of the Child, and the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. The overarching frame of legal violations coupled with initiatives towards empowerment and peace building raises the question of these endeavors as mere attempts of “normalization”14 under occupation, which appear to form part of the development and peace trajectory. The latter falls into the development modus operandi of the international community. Instead of enforcing international law, which would end the occupation, the international community generally has maintained the status quo and cemented power relations with the participation of some of the dispossessed.
Militarized Behavior Seeps into the Psyche and Behavior of Some of the Colonized
If peace-building and empowerment are confronted with obstacles vis-Ă -vis those who engage as oppressors and a population under that oppression, empowerment between the female segment of a population under occupation also has its fair share of divisions. In the past, diverse discourses and actions were deployed by Palestinian women’s autonomous movements. During the first intifada (1987-1993) — the popular civilian struggle against the Israeli occupation — a significant number of women were activists and leaders of civilian resistance.15 Women’s committees were established and affiliated with national liberation organizations in towns, villages and refugee camps. Grandmothers and young girls alike were in the protests, constructed barricades and used their own bodies to shield their men from soldiers. Further, they contributed to the reduction of their community’s economic reliance on Israel.16 Neighborhood committees were established along with home schooling, demonstrating the resilience of the Palestinian community under occupation.17 Yet women’s extraordinary capacity and contributions to the survival of Palestinian society have been marginalized.
Instead of women being enabled to contribute to new forms of peacemaking, what has ensued has been the extensive militarization of Palestinian society, which is apparent through the vehicle of local governing structures that were intended to be temporary. This has been a result of the occupation as well as the infiltration and purchase of an international development paradigm based on unequal yet intersectional relations of power. In the case of Occupied Palestine militarization may be perceived as being derived from a hegemonic interest, coupled with the practices of the colonial power, which seeps into the psyche and behavior of some of those who are colonized, pitting them against one another, dividing them and ultimately, conquering them.
For example, a local governing women’s entity was established in November 2003 “as a response to the Palestinian women’s struggle to achieve their national political and socio-economic rights.”18 A glaring issue of contention was Hamas’ landslide elections victory in 2006. Although Hamas overwhelmingly won the democratic parliamentary elections in Occupied Palestine with 76 seats of the 132-member parliament, it was prevented from governing by the international community.19 Following the insistence that democratic elections be held, the United States and donor countries either discontinued or severely curtailed assistance to any entity that was associated with Hamas. This was significant as the Palestinians were the most foreign-aid dependent nation at the time.20
Domination and Submission
If one reviews women’s empowerment through a postcolonial lens, several immediate questions arise connected to processes of domination and submission. How can women’s empowerment be achieved within Palestinian society when Hamas’ electoral victory — according to the Carter Center, in free and fair elections — was immediately nullified?21 Such nullification negated those who supported Hamas, which constituted the majority in Gaza, one of the most densely populated areas in the world. That population, which includes women, was denied any form of participation, decision-making or even presence.22 One may assume that the women envisioned to benefit from plans for women’s empowerment were not supporters, voters or members of Hamas and were not married to men who were associated with Hamas. The women in Gaza were in fact quintessential subalterns due to their absolute erasure by the governing structures that were deemed appropriate by the international community. Indeed, the lives of many women in Gaza were either extinguished or placed under severe hardship with the massacre of people during Operation Cast Lead in 2008-09.23 The latter is a somber reminder of the difficulties of empowerment and peace-building under the onslaught of occupation, although the ones in power and their supporters may pretend that women’s empowerment and peace can transpire under such conditions.
The local governing structure’s empowerment or gender equality route fits into a model of development that has followed the political sentiment of the international community. The development trajectory of the international community upheld the external suppression of the Palestinian democratic structure and referred to those that were deemed favorable to their interests rather than those who were democratically elected. Emphasis was not placed on addressing and including the entire Palestinian population inside Occupied Palestine. Instead, the focus was on the language of gender, the third Millennium Development Goal, which aims at promoting gender equality and empowering women as well as UNSC Resolution 1325 on women, peace and security, again regardless of the possibilities of implementation under occupation. This is not to underestimate the relevance of these concepts and initiatives. However, it is worth analyzing the local context of struggle, its indigenous characteristics and the rights of the entire Palestinian population. This was replaced with the use of a certain discourse by local governing structures, which at times permitted dominance over the “other” by entering into processes of negotiation that included not only the loss of voice but the acquiescence and adoption of a donor-driven discourse that was once alien.24 Subsequently, various categories of subalternity were created, which entailed the complete exclusion of segments of the population that local governing structures were intended to serve.
Conclusions
To conclude, peace building and empowerment among women cannot take place in the absence of liberation. Asymmetrical power relations where a civilian population is continuously occupied under a colonial state-building process does not lend itself to empowerment or peace for any member of humanity. Instead, the militarization of the societies involved takes hold which confines perception, circumscribes thought and, in turn, determines actions both externally and internally. An ongoing occupation which is a constant condition of violence by Israel renders it challenging for Israeli women to engage in empowerment or peace with the Palestinian women whom they occupy. Indeed, it is patronizing that women who served as conscripts in an occupation army, or are part of a country that engages in an illegal occupation and annexation, should form a partnership of empowerment with those who live under the oppression of colonization. A more realistic option is to seek a new path which facilitates localized empowerment and peace initiatives on the ground, as well as general nonviolent resistance against the occupation by both Israeli and Palestinian women, separately, until the gap in power is minimized.
An in-depth understanding of civil society on the ground may result in more authentic processes of empowerment and peace based on how the people define themselves, their situation and their needs. On the other hand, due to the continuously changing nature of a prolonged occupation and ensuing annexation, Palestinian entities and their plans should serve to facilitate the strengthening of all people and sectors of Palestinian society regardless of political affiliation. This entails the active participation of the people in their self-determination while demanding that the international community and the Palestinian “representatives” comply with their mandates. The fragmentation of the Palestinian nation under occupation renders these initiatives difficult; however, they are not impossible. Fostering belief and cohesion like that which took place in South Africa among anti-Apartheid activists, instead of local divisions, should be a constant objective.25 The only type of empowerment, peace and development that should take place in Occupied Palestine is that which builds on the people’s resilience, sumud (steadfastness)26 and resistance, which challenges the situation of colonialism through occupation. A course of “development” which ignores these elements will only serve to mitigate, rather than eliminate, the root cause that does not allow peace and empowerment to take hold, which is the occupation and current annexation.

Tuesday, 16 July 2013

Middle East: Israel and Palestinian Women Together for Peace

Original Source-

Researcher- Hansa Rochlani

It was an informal, probably even illegal gathering. In 1988, Israeli and Palestinian women met at a cloister in Jerusalem to talk about peace. Soon after, the meetings became a regular occurrence while officials ignored that they were breaking the rule forbidding political contact between Palestinians and Israelis. They were women, after all.
“For a long time women were left out of the process,” said human rights and peace activist Simone Susskind. “The role of women in the peace negotiation is essential to reaching peaceful solutions.”
And so it is: This informal group of women created a two-state solution years before it became a discussion point in peace negotiations. And the principal they believed in, that women should be, absolute must be, involved in conflict resolution and peace building, was recognized 12 years later when the United Nations adopted the landmark Resolution 1325 on October 31, 2000.
“The most important thing 1325 has done is raise awareness of what has happened to women in conflict situation,” said Pam DeLargy, chief of the Humanitarian Response Group of the United Nations Population Fund. “1325 has made it a standard practice now for women’s groups and feminist getting involved in the decision making process of their countries.”
Capitalizing on the UN resolution and in an effort to strengthen it, Israeli and Palestinian women created the International Women’s Commission (IWC) five years later. In addition to Israeli and Palestinian members, the organization includes international members such as United Nations Development Fund for Women (UNIFEM) chief InĂ©s Alberdi, Liberia President Ellen Johnson Sirleaf and the Finnish President Tarja Halonen, who together direct the IWC.
The main goal of the organization is advancing the role of women in their communities, in order to increase their participation in the paralyzed peace negotiations between Israel and Palestine. It works parallel with the stated goal of UN Resolution 1325: to stop the marginalization of women in the Arab-Israeli conflict.
For 60 years, men of each side – politicians, journalists – have written the narrative of this on-going power struggle. Missiles, suicide bombings, refugee camps, and censorship have taken the prominent role in the battle over territory and historical wrongs. With rare exception, the voices of women on either side have not been heard. However, beneath the public script, women serve as the cultural glue and as healers. They are educators, doctors, politicians, artists, and organization leaders.
Women of each side have forged wisdom out of experience and circumstances. They know what is needed on the ground, and work creatively and tenaciously toward obtaining it. They understand the value of forgiveness in order to progress. They are also educated, articulate, and professionally accomplished. Despite all this, very few women have risen high enough to become involved in the peace negotiation process.
Public discourse between Israelis and Palestinians was considered taboo before the Oslo Accords were signed in 1993 but with the advent of the peace process and a glimmer of hope on the horizon for a just and bloodless resolution, it became acceptable to both parties to hold face-to-face dialogues.
Susskind, who has been with the organization since its inception and serves on its international steering committee, says that the IWC favours a resolution that incorporates gender perspective in addressing not only the outstanding issues – including a full cessation of settlements, the recognition of Jerusalem as the capital of two states, and an equitable solution to the refugee question based on UN Resolution 194 – but also in guaranteeing human security and the right to life with dignity for both peoples.
A rocky path
Despite a seemingly small number of achievements so far, Susskind is proud of the young organization. “The women have a very good working relationship, and they have learned to cooperate together on many levels,” she said.
However, it has been a rocky path over the past few years. During the Gaza War, relationships were severed and Palestinian women refused to engage in dialogue with their Israeli counterparts, making the unity of the groups nearly impossible and endangering the IWC’s progress up to that point.
Advocates say things are slowly getting on track. In June in Madrid, women leaders attending a conference on ” Advancing Women’s Leadership for Sustainable Peace in the Palestinian-Israeli Conflict and Worldwide” hosted by the UNIFEM and the IWC, ended the meeting with a joint call for a just and peaceful resolution of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, including an end to the three-year-old blockade of the Gaza Strip.
Mariam Ikermawi, the director of the Jerusalem Centre for Women and a Palestinian living in East Jerusalem, said the IWC gave women a voice and provided a new approach to peace talks. She credits the organization for treating women as agents of change rather than forgotten victims. Still, Ikermawi referred to the IWC as a “high-profiled women’s club,” saying that few Israeli and Palestinian women are aware of its existence.
“It’s mostly popular outside its region, and as there wasn’t real work on the grassroots level, you won’t really find anybody who knows the IWC but the people who are in the same field,” said Ikermawi. “We are speaking about a body that exists but doesn’t really have momentum within its own societies.”
Susskind admits that this is one of the IWC main shortfalls, saying that the organization’s biggest challenge is getting the message out. “I agree with this criticism, I know that the IWC has had little impact in Israel and Palestine because we did not manage to engage women together,” said Susskind. But she also adds that the IWC is learning from its mistakes and intends to address them at the IWC’s next meeting in Jericho.
Anat Saragusti, one of the founders of IWC and the executive director of Agenda – Israeli Centre for Strategic Communications, says that the IWC plays a large role in trying to raise awareness among decision-makers all over the world. “We meet frequently with high level international figures to influence them about the urgency of the situation, about the need to integrate women’s perspectives into the process – about the need to solve the political conflict through political means, and not with arms and power,” said Saragusti, insisting that core issues must be dealt with head on and not avoided. “We talk about a fair solution based on a two-state solution on the borders of June 4, 1967, with Jerusalem as the capital of both states.”
The first female TV correspondent in the Gaza strip, a lawyer by training as well as a human rights activist, Saragusti gives a negative assessment of IWC achievements so far: “We failed, we don’t have peace, and women are not on the negotiating table,” she said. Now that the month-long direct talks between Palestinians and Israelis are deadlocked, the great challenge confronting the IWC is mobilizing the Israeli and Palestinian public in favour of its approach.
But Susskind says the organization is young and needs to time to get on track. She adds that she is sure time will make a difference. “I’m hopeful that after five years of existence we are better prepared,” said Susskind. “We have young women, better working relationships, and we are working better together. I’m not pessimistic – if I was, then I wouldn’t be here working.”
On September 15, IWC circulated a position paper to advance the Israel-Palestine negotiations in which stressed the need to “ensure the meaningful participation of women and the inclusion of women’s perspectives in the negotiations, as mandated by United Nations Security Council Resolution 1325 and 1889.” This, it said, was necessary “to adopt a new approach both to avoid past mistakes and to ensure far greater chances for success”. (Oct. 2010)

Monday, 15 July 2013

A Short History of Women in Black

Original Source- http://www.womeninblack.org/en/history

Researcher- Hansa Rochlani

"Women in Black" was inspired by earlier movements of women who demonstrated on the streets, making a public space for women to be heard - particularly Black Sash, in South Africa, and the Madres de la Plaza de Mayo, seeking the "disappeared" in the political repression in Argentina. But WIB also shares a genealogy with groups of women explicitly refusing violence, militarism and war, such as the Women's International League for Peace and Freedom formed in 1918, and the Greenham Common Women's Peace Camp in the UK and related groups around the world opposing the deployment of US missiles in the eighties.
Beginnings in Israel
Women in Black as we know it today began in 1988 in Israel. In 1987, 20 years after Israel occupied the West Bank and Gaza, the Palestinian intifada began. In response Israeli Jewish women began to stand in weekly vigils in public places, usually at busy road junctions. Starting in Jerusalem, the number of vigils in Israel eventually grew to almost forty. In the north of Israel, where the concentration of Arab communities is greatest, Palestinian women who are Israeli citizens were also active in Women in Black groups. Many local WIB groups made contact with women across the Green Line engaged in support work, e.g. visiting Palestinians in Israeli prisons.
Establishing a formula for action
At WIB vigils, women carried placards saying "End the Occupation" and closely related messages. The focus was quite precise, in order to be able to draw in a wide group of women. The vigils were predictable: same site, regular intervals. The women wore black. Although they were not particularly silent in most Israeli locations, as they have become in some countries since, there was no chanting. They were seen by, and provoked reactions from, many passers-by on foot and in vehicles, some of whom heckled and abused them, both in sexualized terms ("whores") and for their politics ("traitors"). Their policy was not to shout back but to maintain silence and dignity.
In other countries, including Canada, the USA, Australia, and many European countries, Women in Black vigils soon began to be organized in support of those in Israel. In Berkeley, California, for example, Women in Black has been standing weekly since 1988. In the UK at this time, women (mainly Jewish, with Palestinians and others) picketed the offices of the Israeli state airline, El Al.
Italian women pick up the theme
In Italy a group of women had started a project they called "Women Visiting Difficult Places" which aimed to promote dialogue between women on different "sides" in countries where there is conflict. They visited Israel and Palestine in 1988, and gave support to Women in Black there. They returned to found their own WIB, Donne in Nero, which soon had weekly vigils in Roma, Milano, Bologna, Torino, Ravenna, Padova and Verona. Large numbers of women from Italy have maintained a programme of visits to Israel/Palestine for more than a decade. In 1989 they helped promote an event "Time for Peace" in Jerusalem, involving a great human chain around the walls, and in 1996 shared with Bat Shalom in organizing the event "Sharing Jerusalem".
The Gulf War
At the time of the Gulf War (in 1991, following Iraq's invasion of Kuwait) it became more difficult for Israeli women openly to support Palestinians because of Arafat's public support for Saddam Hussein. Later (1994) the Oslo Accords between the Israeli government and the PLA suggested progress towards peace, so that protest seemed less necessary. Women in Black vigils ended in all but four locations in Israel. However a number of women's peace conferences in Jerusalem between 1994 and 2001 involved many of the original WIB network, some of whom remained active in this interval in Bat Shalom, TANDI, and other women's peace organizations.
In contrast to the situation in Israel, in many other countries the Gulf War stimulated women to oppose the US-led bombardment of Iraq.For instance, in London a group of women demonstrated as Women Against War in the Gulf. Later some of them would rename themselves Women in Black.
Women in Serbia respond to war
Soon after, when Yugoslavia began to disintegrate and war broke out between the former Yugoslav republics, some of the Italian women visited feminist activists in Belgrade, which led to a similar form of organization and action there. Women in Black in Belgrade (Zene u Crnom) was formed on October 9 1991. Explicitly feminist, they have been actively opposing nationalist aggression and masculine violence ever since.
Zene u Crnom had a strong and challenging street presence, with regular weekly vigils in Republic Square in Belgrade from 1991. They work in partnership with men refusing to serve in the military, and have maintained an extensive programme involving public statements, writing and publishing, educational workshops and seminars, and organizing international visits and meetings.
A strong group in Spain
A Spanish WIB network, Mujeres de Negro, were by now strong and active. They helped find refuge, respite and a public platform in Spain for women from the Yugoslav region. It was with an important input from Mujeres de Negro and Donne in Nero that the women of Zene u Crnom in Belgrade organized a series of ten annual international encounters at different locations in the former Yugoslavia, which have been an important force creating and expanding the international network.
Women in Black spreads to other countries
During the sequence of wars that began in 1992, in Croatia and Bosnia., Women in Black groups sprang up in many more countries, supporting Zene u Crnom Belgrade in their opposition to nationalist aggression. Women got together in Belgium (a French-speaking group Femmes en Noir in Brussels and Flemish-speaking group Vrouwen in het Zwart in Leuven). Women in Black London took its name at this time, starting to hold weekly or monthly vigils in Trafalgar Square, in central London.
It is impossible to name all the separate groups in the various countries that emerged since the middle nineties, but the reader is encouraged to look them up on their individual pages on this website. Some groups adopted the formula of silent vigils, wearing black. Others (for instance the Bay Area WIB in California and WIB in Tokyo) have found it more effective, for instance, to process in single file, silently, through shopping areas, or to use masks, giant puppets and drums. Many women from these groups took up the practices of visiting war zones in support of women there. There were many visits to Belgrade, Zagreb, Sarajevo and other towns and cities of the region.
As always in women's movements, and especially perhaps in groups opposing violence, there are many lesbians active in Women in Black. It has been productive to make connections between violence in war and in everyday life, including the violence of homophobia, misogyny and racism. A particularly strong and supportive relationship was formed between lesbians in the Leuven Vrouwen in het Zwart and Zene u Crnom.
And other continents
Women in Black in India began in 1992. When the Babri Masjid, an ancient mosque, was torn down by Hindu fundamentalists and violence engulfed India, women were the main victims. WIB in the city of Bangalore have stood every Thursday in silent vigils on the streets, in the market squares and in the Gandhi Peace Park, protesting the wars against women.
Women in Black in the Philippines began in 1995. The Asian Women's Human Rights Council and the Lila Pilipina, an organization of former comfort women, gather often in front of the Japanese Embassy in Manila, dressed in black, demanding compensation for the wartime crime of sexual slavery by the Japanese army in World War II.
A landmark occasion in the nineties was a massive Women in Black vigil (an estimated 3000 women) in Beijing on September 4 1995 that was organized by the Women in Black of India and the Asian Women's Human Rights Council, at the time of the UN World Conference on Women. They called for "a world safer for women" and an end to wars and armed conflicts.
From 1996, Women in Black in Nepal have stood in silent vigils around the issues of trafficking and violence against women in public places in Katmandu.
In 1998 and 1999 Women in Black groups everywhere had occasion to demonstrate against a sequence of military engagements by the USA, sometimes partnered by the UK, or in the context of NATO. These included continued sanctions and bombing raids against Iraq, the bombing of Sudan and Afghanistan, and the bombardment of Belgrade and other Serbian cities.
Creating an electronic network
It was the Spanish women of Mujeres de Negro, who first saw how crucially important information technology was going to be in linking WIB groups in antiwar action. They were the ones to take the step of setting up an electronic list-serve for Women in Black, at first in Spanish, eventually in English too. Later, in the year 2000 they set up a system of "country coordinators", thus effectively turning WIB into a worldwide net. The information now circulating by e-mail mainly comes from, and goes to, WIB groups. But women with similar aims though using different names and organizational approaches (for instance in Afghanistan and Colombia) are also linked through the list.
Intensified conflict in Israel/Palestine
The renewal of the Palestinian intifada, in late September 2000, after the Al-Aqsa mosque incident, restimulated WIB in Israel. By mid-November women were standing at six sites (Nazareth, Acre, Haifa, Tel Aviv, Jerusalem and the Nachson junction) and this activism continues today in 15 simultaneous vigils, some calling themselves Women in Black and others not.
November 2000 also saw the formation in Israel of the Coalition of Women for a Just Peace, which brings together all the Women in Black vigils in Israel as well as 9 other women's peace organizations. Dressed in black, these women have carried out direct action (e.g., placing a "closure" on the Israeli Defence Ministry by blocking traffic to it), in addition to holding mass Women in Black vigils twice a year, with thousands of women participating.
Groups of women, primarily from Donne in Nero but also from London WIB and elsewhere have been visiting Palestine and Israel since the start of the al-Aqsa intifada to support Palestinians and strengthen links between them and Israeli women peace activists.
The Asian Women's Human Rights Council and El Taller International, two networks of women's human rights organizations in the global south, have held seventeen Courts of Women in different regions and vigils of Women in Black have been held before each Court. There was a very intense and creative demonstration of over 5000 women in Cape Town, South Africa, on the eve of the World Court of Women Against War, For Peace (March 2001). The Women in Black in South Africa stood against war and for peace.
As the Israeli oppression of the West Bank and Gaza intensified, Israeli WIB and the Coalition called, in June and again in December 2001, through the worldwide e-mail coordination, for a day of simultaneous protest. Through this and similar international actions it is estimated that there are more than 150 WIB groups in at least 24 countries.
September 11 2001
After the attacks on US targets on September 11 2001, WIB as an international network speedily agreed and issued a statement. Women in New York and other US locations (as well as other groups worldwide) were quick to stand with an appeal for "Justice not vengeanc". Many groups have subsequently protested against the pursuit by the USA and allies of a "war on terror" in Afghanistan and elsewhere. When the bombing of Afghanistan ended, Italian Donne in Nero went to work with women's groups in Pakistan and Afghanistan.
During 2002 WIB groups everywhere have been actively opposing any extension of military action by the USA and allied governments to attacks on particular states, notably Iraq. But militarism and violence that is less in the international headlines has also been a continuing focus for different Women in Black groups round the world. For instance Mujeres de Negro in Spain coordinated a worldwide action to protest the drug-related war in Colombia, where they have strong connections with women's groups.
The most recent vigil at an all Indian level was held at the Asia Social Forum (in preparation of the World Social Forum at Porto Alegre, Brazil) in Hyderabad on January 4 2003. There were over three thousand women dressed in black protesting Israel's Occupation of Palestine, the war on Iraq and the war crimes of the USA, and other situations of war and armed conflict.
Recognition of WIB's work for peace
Women in Black locally and internationally have received a number of awards in recognition of their work for peace. The worldwide network were awarded the Millennium Women's Peace Prize sponsored by the NGO International Alert and the UN agency UNIFEM, and the following year the network was a nominee for the Nobel Peace Prize. Donne in Nero were awarded the Gold Dove of Peace, an Italian prize, in 2002. The Network was honoured by Church Women United, USA.
Israeli Women in Black won the Aachen Peace Prize (1991); the peace award of the city of San Giovanni d'Asso in Italy (1994); and the Jewish Peace Fellowship's "Peacemaker Award" (2001).
NB: We are painfully aware that this history is far from complete, and is most probably biased due to imbalance in the regions and vigils that have volunteered information. Please help us to build towards a proper history of Women in Black by putting up information on your own web pages.